To be completely honest, I came in to Heart of Darkness expecting for it to have a black and white opinion about imperialism: either it was good or bad. What I didn't expect was for the story to have so many layers, opinions, and contrasts within it. For example, on page 10, Conrad states that good things have come out of imperialism and it gives the reader an impression that imperialism can help society that is living in the so-called "darkness". The excerpt gave the impression that colonialists are good people who want to spread their values and assist the nations in need. All colonialists have morals to back them up even in the face of revolting and uneccessary actions. However, Mason points out to his oblivious aunt that the company's aspirations are for money and for money only. Such goals were referred to in the Congo as well when Mason hears the white settlers obsessing over money and ivory. Despite being sent on this suppossed moral expedition, many settlers treat sick natives with disdain and disregard. Yet, their actions differ from the Eldorado Expedition. In contrast to the Company, the Eldorado Expedition doesn't have any morals, yet their actions are relatively similar. Kurtz is a fine example of the Company. His writings are beautiful, they seem to be moral, yet if one truly looks into them, he will find cruelty within its pages. Unlike the Europeans, Mason notices how calmly and rationally the natives act in the face of danger. He even hints at the possibility that the Europeans are the savages, while the blacks are civilized.
Thus, emerging questions pop into the reader's mind. What is Conrad's position on imperialism? What defines a savage? How does it contrast with civilized? Is imperialism positive if it is backed up by supposed moral aspirations? Does it become cruel when it has no morality? Is it fair for people to work towards a greater purpose when their real concern is earning money and status? Were natives in need of that greater ideal? If people express themselves eloquently about the benefits of such morality, does society have a right to instigate those methods? I am curious about the positive effects of imperialism on the natives. I'd like to think that colonialism did improve several natives' lives and was needed. However, it is truly disturbing to think of all the cruelty natives were forced to endure due to imperialism. And thus, the most important question comes to mind. Was it worth it? Just like in Heart of Darkness, people may never come to a clear opinion.
No comments:
Post a Comment