Sunday, September 18, 2011

Best of Week: Truth

An interesting question was posed to the class which caused our minds to prod about to find the answer. The question was as follows "How are Purity, Chastity, and Modesty enemies and antagonists to the truth?". Charlie raised her hand and responded by explaining that the three sisters hid the ugly truth in their separate ways. I was stunned to a considerable extent. In all of the literature I have read, those three qualities were regarded with reverence not with animosity. Being pure, chaste, and modest was the equivalent to being clean not deceiving. This observation posed my previous beliefs into turmoil.

Often, I was faced with the three qualities in my experiences both in literature and real life. A close friend of mine is an Orthodox Jew who is highly modest in her clothing. She also tends to keep herself pure in more ways than one. My friend considers it a very negative aspect to not have the sisters in your morale. In literature (mostly nineteenth century), women that were known as pure and innocent were viewed in the highest regard, respect, and attraction. A lady who wasn't chaste and naively conquettish was regarded as a corrupt and wretched woman. I never jumped to such conclusions, but agreed with my friend and literature that purity, chastity, and modesty were of an admirable nature.

Virginia Woolf forced me to look at the sisters in a different light. She claimed that innocence covered up the ugly, but imperative truth. I never associated purity with truth and only now started to. Truth is a virtue that was always highly valued to me. Could chastity, modesty, and purity actually contradict it? In Anna Karenina, Kitty was a chaste, pure, and innocent girl. To me, she just seemed a trifle stupid. I only now realized why she always annoyed me. Due to her innocence, Kitty was naive to the point where she often disregarded the truth when it came to her suitors, friends, and family. Her purity lead her to pain and betrayal after truth cruelly looked her in the eye. Perhaps the sisters hid the truth from Kitty as they did so on other occasions. As I thought about the various books I read, those girls who were the epitome of the sisters often met some kind of disappointment. I noticed that my friend also naively regarded some of her relationships which often lead to letdown.

Therefore, I recognize that in many if not most cases purity, chastity, and modesty can hide what is in front of me. I always want to face the truth no matter how troublesome it can be. Virginia Woolf showed me how those qualities can act against a person's best interest. In literature, I will be more skeptical when viewing pure women and the positive identification coming with them. In real life, I will put my best effort in so my friends and I can see whatever society's expectations of a female is trying to repress from us.

No comments:

Post a Comment